A registered capital gain valuer is required by
their registration conditions to be
independent of the parties
to the transaction being valued.
They cannot hold a financial interest in the outcome
of the valuation; they cannot be employed by or
commercially related to the assessee in a way that
compromises their independence; and they must disclose
any relationship that could give rise to a perception
of conflict.
WHY IT MATTERS
This independence requirement is what makes
the registered valuer’s report credible to the
Income Tax Department and the ITAT.
A CA’s in-house property estimate, a broker’s opinion
of the property they sold, or a dealer’s assessment
of an artwork they brokered is not independent.
A Section 34AB registered capital gain
valuer with no commercial interest in the
transaction is independent.